Skip to main content

Table 4 The results on optimization of ground state energy of SK model

From: Gumbel-softmax-based optimization: a simple general framework for optimization problems on graphs

N

I

GSO (\(N_{{\text{bs}}}=1\))a

GSO (\(N_{{\text{bs}}}=128\))a

EvoGSO (\(N_{{\text{bs}}}=128\))b

256

5000

\(-\,\)0.7267(2)/0.99 s

\(-\,\)0.7369(1)/0.96 s

\(-\,\)0.7364(1)/0.89 s

512

2500

\(-\,\)0.7405(2)/2.16 s

\(-\,\)0.7464(1)/2.14 s

\(-\,\)0.7462(1)/2.01 s

1024

1250

\(-\,\)0.7480(2)/4.49 s

\(-\,\)0.7521(1)/4.66 s

\(-\,\)0.7516(4)/4.41 s

2048

400

\(-\,\)0.7524(2)/7.23 s

\(-\,\)0.7555(2)/8.07  s

\(-\,\)0.7557(1)/7.51 s

4096

200

\(-\,\)0.7551(2)/10.46 s

\(-\,\)0.7566(5)/12.78  s

\(-\,\)0.7569(3)/12.80 s

8192

100

\(-\,\)0.7562(1)/25.15 s

\(-\,\)0.7568(8)/49.13 s

\(-\,\)0.7578(5)/49.04  s

  1. We show that the parallel version of our proposed methods and EvoGSO can greatly improve the performance
  2. The best results are denoted in italic. The corresponding standard error of the mean is given in brackets.
  3. aConfiguration: initial \(\tau\) = 20, final \(\tau\) = 1, and learning rate = 1
  4. bConfiguration: initial \(\tau\) = 20, final \(\tau\) = 1, learning rate = 1, cycle \(T_1\) = 100, and substitution ratio 1/u = 1/8